The highly anticipated Coachella Festival promised, at the very least, a spectacle worthy of intense scrutiny. It was the first U.S. festival to attempt to capture the feel of European festivals such as Reading and Glastonbury; it also occurred close on the heels of this year’s disastrous Woodstock Festival in New York. Choler couldn’t let such an event come and go without dispatching a couple of agents to investigate the hubbub. They chose us because — well, everyone else in the office seemed to have plans for the weekend.
We Danced. We Rocked. We Sneezed. We Occasionally Feared For Our Lives.
The temperatures were hot, the crowds mellow, our noses runny. (Wouldn’t you know, the entire polo field seemed covered in Bermuda grass). But despite backstage rumors of infuriating disorganization, attendants experienced little but smoothly run facilities and energetic performances from a wide, wide range of musical artists.
The good news for both fans and promoters alike is that Coachella bore zero resemblance to Woodstock ‘99 — except, of course, in that music was featured at both events. The issues that some people blamed for causing such a ruckus at Woodstock (overpriced water and food, bathrooms that quickly degenerated into mini toxic-waste dumps, a lineup of bands that emphasized thuggery) were expertly addressed at Coachella. The promoters provided cheap water (and plenty of it, though waits to acquire it sometimes seemed interminable) and tasty food at halfway decent prices (I scored a heaping plate of Chinese food, including shrimp tempura and more chow mein than I could hope to ingest, for under $9 — more than your average takeout but better than a sit-down meal). The event staff was courteous, the bathrooms cleaned frequently.As promised, marketing was kept — at least on this first day — unobtrusive. Best of all, an under-capacity crowd made for a delightfully spacious environment. The promoters deserve credit for intentionally underselling the venue to accommodate attendants’ desire for personal space.
Only once did the event threaten to erupt into violence. Shortly before agit-pop ensemble Rage Against The Machine stormed the main stage late on Day 2, fans of the group began packing — and we’re talking Sardine City here — the area in front of the stage. Event staff attempted to use steel girders and poles to shore up a heavily strained barrier between the crowd and the stage, but eventually all press and photographers were evacuated from the pit for fear the barrier would break and a tsunami of sweaty 20-something flesh would make us all permanent fixtures of the Empire Polo Fields. The press pit remained off-limits through Tool’s set for safety reasons as well. To the best of my knowledge (which is scant, given that we each spent our day running our legs down to stumps scurrying from one place to the next, and so missed a few details here and there), nothing worse than the odd case of heat exhaustion or head-squashing crowd-surfing occurred in the more vigorous moshing areas.
The only real problem — if you can really call it a problem — was an overabundance of great acts. At any given time, three or four great (and at times, legendary) performers were playing in different areas of the venue. Good luck catching every band worth watching.
There Is A Light That Will Never Go Out: Two Perspectives on the Morrissey Phenomenon:
Sean: The biggest surprise of the festival was Morrissey mania. A staggering number of people attended the event simply to see Morrissey perform on Day 1. Moz owned this crowd. Countless cars in the parking lot blared old Moz and Smiths tunes. Inside the venue, maybe four in 10 people were wearing Morrissey-oriented T-shirts. When he took the stage in the early evening, the crowd went absolutely out of its mind — which has to encourage a guy who hasn’t released an album in about two years and who is currently “between labels.”
Truthfully, Moz just doesn’t do it for me like he used to. Back in the day (say, sophomore year of high school), I would’ve killed a family member for a chance to get as close to him as I managed to get at Coachella (gotta love that photo pass).It would’ve thrilled me to bits when he played “Meat Is Murder” and “Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me,” two smoldering classics from his days with the Smiths. I confess to a slight pang of anticipation over pre-show rumors that he might reunite with estranged Smiths songwriting partner and guitarist Johnny Marr. (Their pairing did not occur; Marr, one of many no-shows at Coachella, did not even appear to play his new role as Beck’s guitarist.) However, as a 20-something who’s finally comfortable in his own skin, it interested me more to eat some dinner, drink a beer and grab a few moments to myself on an uncrowded expanse of grass than it did to watch Moz run through the same shtick you see him run through on videos from 1991. Still, I have to marvel at the man’s Latino fan base, which is as devoted a throng of idolaters now as it was 10 years ago.
Eric: Bad memories don’t particularly come rushing back to you while standing for hours in the hot sun. They prefer to circle like vultures just outside the periphery of your vision. The 800-pound bird of prey that was Morrissey’s impact on Coachella hovered above me before I even got there, though it took me a while to notice it stalking me. On the bill, Morrissey was linked with the Chemical Brothers, and a friend horrified me by suggesting that the big-beat maestros might actually team up with Morrissey’s mordant melodrama. Egad. Thankfully, that unholy pairing never occurred. The first car in the Coachella lot we passed should have clued me in to the gaggle of fans awaiting the call of their master’s voice, but it wasn’t until walking past an absurdly long line with more varieties of Smiths and Morrissey T-shirts that I thought possible that I discerned the army of followers that Morrissey’s appearance inspired to endure the torrid weather.
My past experiences with the Mozzer have turned me bitter. In college, I spent over a year with a roommate whose play list consisted exclusively of the Smiths and Morrissey. Said roommate would extol the wit of songs like “Frankly, Mr. Shankley” and attempt to torment my carnivorous soul with “Meat Is Murder.” I tried not to feel too contemptuous. Everyone has their own tastes, and though I feel that most of Morrissey’s material is most appropriate for self-absorbed high schoolers (not that I didn’t go through the same stage; I just got pissed off at the world and bumped NWA), I kept to myself my real feelings toward those who wore black T-shirts — or worse, black fishnet stockings to go with their black Morrissey T-shirts. I thought of the torment that surrounds adolescents east of Orange County, Calif., (I myself spent three misbegotten years in Riverside) and understood for a moment. Then I heard the bass thumping from a DJ tent and followed my bobbing head to a different beat.“I’m Seeing Robots”: Electronic Music at Coachella
Sean: Aside from the Morrissey phenomenon and the noticeable presence of Rage and Tool fans on Day 2, the Coachella Festival belonged to the almighty breakbeat. Anyone who dismissed electronica as an invention (one of many) concocted by record labels to sell more copies of certain records may now have to eat their words; if the Coachella lineup is at all representative of the current direction of modern music, electronica is not only here to stay but also slowly forcing rock to evolve as well. Two of the most intense, widely attended performances of Day 1 were delivered by block-rockers the Chemical Brothers and ambient-techno auteurs Underworld, while Moby provided a viable — and popular — electronic alternative to Tool’s performance on Day 2.
The Chemical Brothers go over well in arena-rock settings because they bring wild improvisations and larger-than-life visuals to their performances — just like an arena-rock act. They also know how to work a crowd.When “Block Rockin’ Beats” emerged from a long, initially unidentifiable mix of frenetically programmed beats, the heat-exhausted crowd managed to find energy reserves enough to erupt into a dance frenzy. Similarly, Underworld (who headlined the smaller second stage) bonded with their crowd early on and relied on vocalist-guitarist Karl Hyde’s magnetic presence to manipulate the crowd’s emotions from one song to the next. By the time they closed their set with a medley from their latest album, Beaucoup Fish, they had worked the crowd up to a synergistic catharsis — all of it without testosterone-laden exhortations to the crowd or playing “hard” music. Underworld knows how to read its audience’s readiness for a new direction and temper the flow of their show to match.
Second stage headliner Moby deserves the festival’s Spirit Award for turning out the most enthusiastic performance of Day 2. During his self-effacing but always charming between-songs banter, Moby kept his crowd’s vibe positive by extolling Coachella’s virtues in comparison to other events at which he has appeared (among them, the now infamous Woodstock ’99).His enthusiasm for the event — and for his music — created an ebulliently joyful atmosphere in his area of the venue. He concluded his set by standing atop his keyboard, arms thrust skyward, symbolizing the energy that coursed through the festival on both days.
Electronic music dominated the three smaller performance tents as well. Day 1’s “Sahara” tent lineup featured two hour sets from techno’s progenitors — the Detroit DJs Kevin Saunderson, Derrick May, Juan Atkins and Richie Hawtin, all of whom spun a mix of dance tracks that pointed to techno’s roots while exhibiting its potential for adaptation to new styles and technological innovations. On Day 2, ambient techno superstars Autechre defined minimalism in one DJ tent, playing crouched behind their laptop computers with no lights shining on them. I snapped one digital picture of them before realizing that I’d left the lens cap on the camera, but the all-black shot probably embodies the duo’s sound as much as their actual physical appearance.
Turntablism and electronica even flavored the more rock-oriented bands on the bill. Scottish band Bis played a disco- and techno-inflected set of high-energy power pop; Spiritualized played an atmospheric set worthy of any ambient techno trip-out artist; former Jane’s Addiction and Porno for Pyros frontman Perry Farrell made a solo appearance with an electronica backup ensemble, turning out a drum ‘n’ bass cover of Led Zeppelin’s “Whole Lotta Love” (and true to form, managed to talk and sing about dolphins and the rainforest about halfway through his set); Beck featured the highly respectable skills of DJ Swamp, who provided an ear-bending interlude between Beck’s main set and encore.
The Funky Four Plus One Make an Appearance: Hip-Hop at Coachella
No, I don’t mean the old-school hip-hop group, though they attended Coachella in spirit. To break it down for those who don’t know, the “four pillars” of hip-hop are MCing, DJing, break dancing (or B-Boyin’, depending on who you ask), and graffiti art. The “plus one” would be beat boxing, represented at Coachella by Rahzel and Click tha Supa Latin, both masters at producing beats with nothing but the mouths and lungs their mommas gave ’em.MCin’:
Coachella’s organizers must be congratulated for learning from the Woodstock fiasco and avoiding any drama under the white-hot sun. Their true brilliance, however, comes in learning from Lollapalooza to never put Kool Keith, the legendary MC who was frontin’ schizo long before Ol’ Dirty Bastard burst onto the scene, on the actual bill, or he won’t show. Don’t tell anyone, not even the lowly press, that Keith will arrive in the Sahara tent on Sunday ‘cause if you expect him, then the good Doctor, being the unorthodox man that he is, will have to defy your expectations. If, however, you make a last-minute call to the self-proclaimed Black Elvis, begging him to fill in for one of a few hip-hop no-shows (Black Eyed Peas, anyone?), boom, he shows, decked out in a fake wig and a cape.
Besides Keith, the art of the microphone was well represented by the few groups Coachella saw fit to invite. Essentially, it looks as though they peered down the Interscope roster, crossed out Dr. Dre and Eminem as being too inflammatory and came up with underground cats Jurassic 5, Ugly Duckling and Black Eyed Peas (an aforementioned no-show). Ugly Duckling put in a decent set on the second stage (referred to in the festival program as the “Outdoor Theater”) but served mostly as a mellow warm-up for Gil Scott-Heron. Scott-Heron, a.k.a. the Last Poet, dropped some science and hopefully enlightened anyone who thought that “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised” originated with Public Enemy. (Scott-Heron cut off the song after a verse, joking that he had heard so many versions of the song, he no longer knows which was which.) In today’s hip-hop world, where political statements only peep through the cracks of a playa-gold paved road, it was a true privilege to see Scott-Heron perform.
The art of the MC was perhaps best put down by the Jurassic 5, who made good on their claim to “make four MC’s sound like one.” Their music melds an old-school sensibility with a wide range of shifting vocal rhythms, all set to the brilliant DJ work of Cut Chemist and Nu-Mark. The humor shown by their sitcom-theme adaptations, notably their play on “One Rhyme [Day] at a Time” brings some much-needed levity into the cynical, materialistic hip-hop of the 90’s. Unfortunately, with just an EP plus some singles material (and a new album dropping in 2000), they seemed preoccupied with stretching out the show, e.g., the featured appearances by Click tha Supa Latin (widely regarded as the West Coast Rahzel) and his son (widely regarded as Click tha Supa Latin’s son). I could have done without the kid doing his Slick Rick imitation, but the crowd loved it, so maybe I’m just a cynical old 24-year-old who doesn’t like kids.
While Coachella represented the MC better than any hip-hop-inclusive festival to date, I hope for the next event, they’ll look beyond the Interscope roster and try to bring in some artists who don’t have so much record-label clout behind them. There are any number of MC’s out there who need the exposure and plenty, like Black Star and KRS-One, who can rock a party and educate.On the Wheels of Steel:
Hip-hop DJing was everywhere at Coachella, served up on steaming plates of black vinyl prepared just right for the crowd’s pleasure. The DJs gave up too many mixes to name that brought things back to the old school, bumping that good hip-hop and electro funk for the crowd. Sometimes there was too much of a good thing –(I heard at least two DJ’s drop the sure-to-burn Brand Nubian track “Punks Jump Up”) but most represented with more imaginative selections.
DJ Shadow, a.k.a. Josh Davis, summed up the tone perfectly during his Day 2 set, sermonizing with his hands and delivering a set that swung wide of the obvious or expected. Shadow dropped nothing but gems, some by others and some his own, always managing to inflect them just a bit to freak the uniqueness. His turntable work seemed especially enlightened when he manhandled the synth noise from “Public Enemy Number One.” Shadow’s at his best when slowly building new patterns out of old music and embroidering tracks like “Building Steam With a Grain of Salt” with scratch work and ominous intonations from vocal samples that perfectly frame his turntable masterpieces. He typifies the contradiction of the DJ, constructing a personality out of samples and yet submerging his own identity beneath his music. Shadow even told crowd that they didn’t have to look at him, that they “could even look at each other” if they so chose. The crowd, anxious to see him go to work, scoffed at the notion.The Invisibl Skratch Piklz DJ crew, represented by Q-Bert, Mix Master Mike and A-Trak, were considerably more flamboyant. The show brought Q-Bert and Mike, arguably the best the Piklz have to offer, together for the first time in ages, and despite (or perhaps because of) playing an improvised set thrown together hastily, the ISP absolutely ripped it up.
The session proved to be educational as well, as Yoga Frog’s play-by-play broke down the chemistry of the techniques used, detailing the switchover as Mike — no, now A-Trak’s on the drums, and Mike’s scratching in a guitar sample. The Skratch Piklz blessed the session for well over an hour, with numerous highlights. (My personal favorite being Q-Bert’s stuttered beat juggle of LL Cool J’s “Rock the Bells”). Whether scratching over beats slow or fast, the ISP crew hones their precision to laserlike dimensions — and that’s within a few microns, y’all. They’re definitely on some microscopic shit. Of course, the entire festival proved that when you think things are as hot as they can get, they’re probably just about to get hotter. And things heated up to supernova extremes when Rahzel hit the stage for a historic collaboration with the Piklz.
Super DJ (The Human Beatbox, the Godfather of Noyez)
Rahzel, in the course of the day, battled not one, not two, but four DJ’s. Operating without his crew (the Roots), the only thing he didn’t do Sunday was battle it out with the Jurassic 5’s Click tha Supa Latin (and I’d be willing to bet they had it out backstage at some point). Rahzel started things off nicely, highlighting the second stage with Transformer effects, samples galore and even rocking the mic a few times with tracks off of his solo album, Make the Music 2000. He battled it out with his DJ, JS-One (who you can hear on the Return of the DJ II compilation), setting down beats with his mouth and leaving it to JS-One to match it on the turntables. It may seem like an unfair match-up, but Rahzel has at his disposal as many samples as his mind can store, while a DJ is limited to the contents of his record collection (always pared down for live shows). Rahzel also earned the prize for non sequitur of the festival when he gave a shout-out to “All the ladies in the house with real hair.” I tried as hard as I could, but I didn’t see a single weave the whole weekend, so maybe Rahzel was just channeling some of Kool Keith’s insanity vibe.
Battling his own DJ in a set routine is one thing, but going against DJs (Q-Bert and Mix Master Mike) who were “asked” to retire from the world DJ competition (held annually in New York City) because of their superior skills forced Rahzel to bring his art to another level. Rahzel’s mental crate was bursting with goodness, letting him give props to the West Side with a “California Love” sample, move on to the syncopated beat and hook for Nore’s “Oh No,” and wrap things up with the classic “All That Scratchin’s Making Me Itch” — at which point the crowd just lost it. Picking up on the Piklz’ educational vibe, Rahzel broke down his beats, displaying for the crowd in slow motion exactly how he could vocalize a beat and lyrics simultaneously.
B-Boys and Graf Art
Actually, while there were hip-hop inspired paintings (in one DJ tent, a crew of artists spent all day adorning blank canvases with hip-hop inspired displays), I didn’t see a single person bombing the canvas (or anything else) with spray cans. At least there was a break dancing clinic put on for people chillin’ in the Oasis tent. The L.A. Breakers put it down on both days, not with so much poppin’ and lockin’ but with a good amount of backspins and headspins to hype up the crowd. Although I wish the crowd could have seen the subtle shadings and spray-can technique of a gifted graf artist, I think the festival as a whole represented the realm of hip-hop to a good degree.
I was happy to see hip-hop but thrilled to see how many non-hip-hop acts gave their respects to the art form. After all, as much as hip-hop derives from James Brown, it also goes back to Afrika Bambaataa, who sampled electronic-music pioneers Kraftwerk on his trademark track “The Planet Rock.” All the divisions between so-called electronica genres and hip-hop just represent branches forking from the same tree.I’ve been resentful of people pilfering hip-hop, as when the Crystal Method built a fan base out of a Rakim sample on their song “Busy Child” (overstating the fact maybe) and landed a Gap commercial, all with fans probably not knowing jack about the R. That irked me a bit. My annoyance at this, however, runs contrary to the sample principle of hip-hop; by all accounts, Lord Finesse was thrilled when Fatboy Slim took his voice for “Rockafeller Skank.” All I want to see is hip-hop getting its proper dues after being the media’s whipping child for so long in the 80’s. With Ming & FS, Mr. Scruff, DJ Cam and others setting things off to the old school at Coachella, my indignant stance softened, and soon I accepted the notion that everything is everything, and music is music.
But wait! There are more epiphanies! DJ Swamp, Beck’s DJ, simply ripped it, beat juggling bizarre noises to put his own personal stamp on what’s long been a hip-hop art form. If every rock band wants to have a DJ, that’s fine, but they better bring some skills to the table or get off the stage. DJ Swamp officially raised the bar at Coachella. I was also pleasantly surprised with MC Dynamite, who Reprazents with Roni Size’s crew. I, like many hip-hop heads, tend to malign drum ‘n’ bass MCs, who complement and play up to the DJ, unlike American hip-hop, which emphasizes the man on the mic and leaves the DJ in the background. Dynamite reminded me that MC stands for “master of ceremonies,” whose job it is to move the crowd. He didn’t do it by ordering the crowd to get hyped; he just moved things along, narrated the brilliant Roni Size set and threw in verses along the way that blended perfectly with his continuing dialogue. American hype men could stand to learn something from the more understated (but no less energetic) approach of MC Dynamite.
The Revolution Will Not Be Testosteronized
All in all, despite the ominous presence of bulked-up males, Coachella unfolded and concluded pleasantly. On Day 2, the Rage and Tool fans remained ensconced within the food-court and beer-vendor areas for most of the day (ah, nothing quells violence like gallons of beer and prolonged exposure to scorching sunlight), while other attendants happily absorbed historic sets from a truly diverse lineup of artists. Cibo Matto made one of the few female-fronted appearances (Bis, Breakbeat Era, DJ Rap and Neotropic rounding out the festival’s estrogen quotient), serving up some tight, funk- and hip-hop influenced pop and indulging the crowd in their food madness (songs include the anthemic “Know Your Chicken” and “Sci-Fi Wasabe”). Medeski, Martin and Wood used their 45 minutes on the main stage to remind the audience of jazz’s influence on rock, rap and techno; Beastie Boy keyboardist Money Mark delivered a laid-back set of mellow organ music perfectly suited for a lazy Sunday afternoon.
The festival’s energy only slightly shifted from the excitement of discovery to the thrall of thuggery when Rage Against The Machine delivered their brutally uncompromising performance. The audience’s burgeoning mob mentality actually compelled an MC to exhort fans to use their heads and not get out of hand during the set, and people were able to keep it together for the rest of the show. Rage frontman Zach de la Rocha performed with laryngitis and “still kicked all your asses,” Tool vocalist Maynard Keenan informed the crowd. Keenan joined Rage in a rare collaboration to assist de la Rocha on vocals before his own band closed the festival with their circus of the bizarre. During Tool’s intense set of prog-rock on crack, Keenan wailed and gyrated spasmodically in nothing but a G-string while his band hammered out a string of soul-searing songs from their albums Undertow, Aenima and a forthcoming record. Nudity made a prolonged and decidedly untitillating appearance with the help of the group’s surreal backing films and a performance by two nude acrobats who scaled ropes and hung far above the stage from their feet during the final 20 minutes of the show.
Pass on the Bizkit and Hold the Korn
All told, Coachella was an unexpected triumph. A U.S. festival hasn’t been this much fun since the first Lollapalooza pounded the first nail into alternative rock’s coffin. Our only caveat to the promoters of Coachella would be not to take the lack of major violence at today’s show as an invitation to include more heavy rock bands on Coachella’s 2000 bill (purportedly already in the planning phase). The general opinion of the journalists, artists and event staff with whom we casually conversed was that the festival ran successfully primarily because it avoided certain acts that encourage mindless brutality. Intelligent metal bands like Rage and Tool work well because they compel audiences to use their brains as much as their bodies while rocking out. It is possible to find catharsis without beating on one’s neighbor or sexually assaulting female crowd surfers. Brains ruled at Coachella — people rocked, people danced, Piklz skratch’d. For at least one weekend, the whole desert bounced.